Should I See a Christian Therapist or a Secular One?

If you're a Christian looking for a therapist, you've probably asked yourself this question: should I see a Christian therapist, or a secular one?

It's rarely just a logistics question. There's usually a hope underneath it, or a fear. Sometimes both.

For some women, the answer feels obvious. She wants a Christian therapist because she wants to do the deep work, and she wants to do it with someone who can hold space for her faith and shares similar values. She doesn't want to spend her sessions explaining what she believes, or translating her faith for someone who sees the world completely differently. And she doesn't want to sit across from someone whose beliefs and values oppose hers, because that shared ground is part of what helps her feel safe enough to go deep.

For other women, it's more complicated. They believe in Jesus, but they're still figuring out how their faith fits into their lifestyle, their behaviors, their relationships. And they're scared that a Christian therapist will judge them, or preach at them, especially about the parts of their life the church doesn't always leave room for questions about. The parts they're not even sure what they think yet.

Both of those women are asking a good question. So let's actually answer it.

The label doesn't guarantee anything

Here's the honest part: the words "Christian therapist" don't guarantee anything.

I look at the "Christian counselor" label as a door. It can open a different level of understanding, or commonality. Like, "oh, this person comes from a similar belief system, where I can bring all parts of me, and not leave some parts in the waiting room."

A door can offer a point of connection. But it doesn't guarantee it. The label tells you something about the therapist's framework. It doesn't tell you how it will actually feel to sit in the room with them.

And that's true of every other part of choosing a therapist, too. A shared race or background, a therapist who's a woman, sessions online or in person. Any of those can open a door to feeling understood. None of them, on their own, promise you'll be safe there.

So what do you actually do?

You have the consultation, and you ask.

Ask how the therapist brings faith into the room. Ask how they would hold space for the difficult parts you're dealing with, or wondering about. Be brave and honest about what you actually need. This is not the moment to give the polished version.

And then pay attention to how it feels. If you feel judged on that call, that therapist most likely won't be a good fit. If you feel safe, and you're vibing, it's more likely to be a place where you can safely explore the deeper parts of your story.

One more thing, because this matters too: if you start working with someone and, somewhere down the road, the relationship shifts, or you feel a judgment that wasn't there before, you get to say something about it. You can talk to your therapist about it. And if it becomes clear that this isn't a place that allows you to keep exploring, it's okay to find someone else. That decision is always yours.

The goal was never the label. The goal is a room where all of you gets to come in.

How it works in my office

So here's how that actually looks with me.

I don't walk in with an agenda for your faith. I ask. Early on, I'll check in about how you want faith to be part of therapy, if you want it there at all.

For some people, it's a majority part of the work. We pray together. We read Scripture. For others, it never really comes up again. Just knowing I'm a Christian is enough, and we never mention Jesus. Both are completely fine with me.

That's because this part of therapy is like every other part: it's yours. It exists for your needs, not mine.

I'm also not going to get it right every time. I'm human. I may say the wrong thing, or misunderstand something you tell me. When that happens, I'll own it, and we'll work on repairing it. That matters to me.

Mostly, I believe you're the expert of you. I'm in the passenger seat. I assist, I get curious, I point things out, I reflect back what I hear, and I help you make the connections. You're the one driving your own healing.

If you're looking for Christian counseling in Burbank or online across California, and you want faith to be a resource in the room rather than a rule, I'd love to talk. You can book a free 15-minute consultation and ask me exactly these questions.

Next
Next

You Might Be A Good Girl If...